Meet Our Ministers, Staff, Life Coaches, and Facilitators


Rob Allen

Suffice it to say that I am unlike any minister you may know.  I am a lover of people, fun, animals, motorcycles, corvettes, and of course, Jesus.  I am educated with a doctorate in counseling, a seminary graduate, and a retired member of the United Association of Plumbers and Steamfitters.  I am fortunate to be married to Cheryl and together we have five children, seven grand-children, and one great-grandchild.  I return to Hemenway for a second installment after serving churches in Florida and Michigan.  If you happen by my office you will likely hear classic rock as I prepare for Sunday.  I am almost always accessible to folks even when I am not at the office so please feel free to email or text me with questions, concerns, or prayer requests.  I look forward to serving you.  Blessings!!!!

Gay Baker (Organ & Piano)

I grew up in Mitchell/Orleans area near Spring Mill State Park. Began piano lessons at seven years of age and started playing in the church around 12 years of age. Before moving to this area in 2002, I was active for over 25 years in Mitchell Presbyterian church. Served on several committees, taught Sunday school, sang in the choir and was part time accompanist for many years. During that time I also worked for Mitchell community schools, playing for the high school choir and varsity singers. I have been in Evansville/Newburgh area for 15 years and have been a member and active in Newburgh Presbyterian Church since that time, just recently finishing a term serving on the Board of Deacons. Sang in choir and was part time accompanist at first but for many years have been a full-time accompanist.


I have two grown, married children and four grandchildren. My main interest outside of music is spending time with my family, especially my grandchildren. Two of them live in Newburgh and the other two reside in Mitchell. I also am an avid walker and I have completed 13 half marathons in the last 6 years. I am very much looking forward to working with Pastor Recob and accompanying at your Hope service. Thank you for the opportunity to serve our God in this way!

181242_10150800925365653_354765421_n (1)

Jenny Kinney (Contemporary)

JENNY KINNEY is the Contemporary Worship Director at Hemenway.  She studied music at Ball State University and Oakland City University from which she is a graduate. Jenny has served as a pianist at Holy Rosary Catholic Church, Assistant Worship Director, soloist, and pianist/keyboardist at New Life Church in Evansville, Interim Worship Director at Gateway Baptist Church in Newburgh, and Choir Director at Newburgh Presbyterian Church.  In addition to her work at Hemenway, Jenny also works as the Assistant Choir Director at Castle High School, a position she has held for 8 years, and has been a private voice and piano teacher for 20 years.    

Maira Staten (Certified Zumba Instructor)

Maira teachs free Zumba Tuesday each Tuesday evening at 6pm in the church basement.  Maira is an experienced Zumba instructor, who loves the community as much as the community loves her in return.  She has owned her own business, loves God, and looks forward to serving through sweat and laughter.